| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| Category:"Related ethnic groups" needing confirmation |
Keep. Contrary to the nomination, there is some latitude for having maintenance and cleanup cats on article mainspace (cf. Category:Wikipedia infobox cleanup, Category:Wikipedia maintenance). However, if migration of this template-generated category to article talk is to be considered, it should be run with the involvement/consultation of the wikiproject WP:ETHNIC which instituted this (temp) measure; it seems that no-one had provided a notification there that this was under discussion here. Will do so, as if it is to be done will require some further modifications to the project's template banner code |
August 19
|
| Category:- 2007 Disciple of Sanjukta Panigrahi, Joyoti Das |
delete |
August 31
|
| Category:1921 in the Soviet Union |
Speedy Merged - simple, obvious error in naming |
August 18
|
| Category:2006 by day and 2007 by day |
keep (due to the technical difference between these two categories), with closer's recommendation to change the names to Category:2006 current events archives by day and Category:2007 current events archives by day, which requires adjusting the programming on the current events portal |
August 25
|
| Category:24 Hour Design |
delete. × |
August 14
|
| Category:5 th century BC Greek architects |
Merge to Category:Ancient Greek architects × |
August 14
|
| Category:666 Satan |
delete |
August 31
|
| Category:A (band) |
delete |
August 20
|
| Category:A albums |
rename |
August 18
|
| Abarat |
rename/merge as updated |
August 5
|
| Category:Actors with advanced academic degrees |
delete |
August 3
|
| Category:Adaptations of Work by Bertolt Brecht |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:Administrative Reforms |
delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Administrators of British India |
merge |
August 9
|
| Category:Afghanistani musicians |
rename/merge as nominated. Also, Afghanistan shows a demonym of Afghan, Afghan is used throughout WP to denote the people of Afghanistan, and Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2007_July_27#Afghan_people. |
August 20
|
| Category:Afghanistani people by occupation |
Already deleted by |
August 20
|
| Category:Afghanistani people |
merge |
August 5
|
| Category:Afghanistani poets |
merge |
August 5
|
| Category:Afghanistani singers |
rename/merge, same reason as Afghan musicians below. |
August 20
|
| Category:African American baseball players |
merge to Category:American baseball players and Category:African American sportspeople per WP:OCAT |
August 3
|
| Category:African international organizations |
rename |
August 30
|
| Category:Airline companies of the United States |
rename |
August 31
|
| Category:Airlines of Faroe Islands |
Speedy delete as empty, nothing to merge and it uses the correctly named category |
August 4
|
| Category:Al-Qaeda killings |
delete |
August 2
|
| Category:Albums without cover art |
rename to Category:Album articles without cover art |
August 6
|
| Category:All My Children |
delete |
August 23
|
| Category:All pages needing completion |
delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Allopathic medicine |
no consensus |
August 17
|
| Category:Alphabet book series |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 7
|
| Category:Alternate versions of |
no consensus; rename for grammar |
August 1
|
| Category:Alternate versions of |
preempted by original closer's decision to rename the category. |
August 12
|
| Category:Alternative high schools |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 10
|
| Category:Alternative metal groups |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 14
|
| Category:American (US) death metal musical groups |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 15
|
| Category:American dietitians |
merge |
August 18
|
| Category:American Gladiators |
no consensus. × |
August 14
|
| Category:American sex offenders |
no consensus |
August 14
|
| Category:Amphoe without coordinates |
repurpose. I could remove the category from the template, but someone is going to manually add the category to all of the talk pages. |
August 7
|
| Category:Amusement Park Images |
speedy rename, capit |
August 24
|
| Category:And Now For Something Completely Different |
delete |
August 15
|
| Category:Annie Lennox singles |
rename |
August 8
|
| Category:Another World |
delete |
August 27
|
| Category:Apartheid legislation in South Africa |
delete |
August 23
|
| Category:Arabic script |
reverse merge; Category:Arabic alphabet to Category:Arabic script |
August 2
|
| Category:Archaeology in Spain |
merge to Category:Archaeology of Spain |
August 23
|
| Category:Areas of Livingston |
rename |
August 12
|
| Category:Art of Ecuador |
merge |
August 23
|
| Category:Articles with broken citations |
no consensus |
August 14
|
| Category:Articles with unsourced statements since April 2006 |
speedily deleted by |
August 14
|
| Category:Artificial lakes |
keep |
August 10
|
| Category:Artists by how they died |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Asclepiadaceae |
rename |
August 23
|
| Category:Association of Cricket Statisticians and Historians |
delete |
August 7
|
| Category:Astronauts from Cincinnati |
merge |
August 12
|
| Category:Astrophysicists |
merge |
August 29
|
| Category:Athletes from Cincinnati |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 12
|
| Category:Attorneys General of Hawaii |
rename |
August 23
|
| Category:Audio books |
rename |
August 8
|
| Category:Australian heavy metal music |
delete per nom and WP:ALBUM |
August 14
|
| Category:Australian television presenters by network |
merge all |
August 12
|
| Authors by franchise |
delete; thanks Mike |
August 2
|
| Category:Avery Small(Football Warrior).jpg |
wrong forum - nominator was trying to nominate Image:Avery Small(Football Warrior).jpg for deletion at WP:IFD, it seems - no such category, anyway. (Non-admin action) |
August 28
|
| Category:Bandini |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:Batibot |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Baton Rouge portal |
merge |
August 16
|
| Category:BBC Radio 1 DJs |
rename/merge as nominated, and above |
August 15
|
| Category:Belgian First Division footballers |
no consensus |
August 1
|
| Category:Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra |
delete |
August 27
|
| Category:Bertolt Brecht dramatic works |
rename to Category:Bertolt Brecht plays |
August 22
|
| Category:Bertolt Brecht |
delete |
August 30
|
| Category:BFCA nominated films |
delete |
August 15
|
| Category:Bill Engvall songs |
Deleted, empty |
August 11
|
| Category:Billy Graham |
delete |
August 20
|
| Category:Birdman |
delete |
August 16
|
| Category:Black and white village |
Delete and listify entry on main Black and white village article |
August 7
|
| Category:Black Winter Olympics medalists |
delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Bob Dylan band members |
delete |
August 2
|
| Category:Books related to Flatland |
delete |
August 4
|
| Category:Bovids |
rename/merge as nominated, per commons, leave redirect |
August 3
|
| Category:Brave New World |
delete |
August 5
|
| Category:Breast Health |
delete, as all contents are already in category:Breast |
August 27
|
| Category:British atrocities |
delete |
August 16
|
| Category:British citizens |
merge. You can discuss removing the cat the article's page since the consensus of merge vs. delete is less clear |
August 12
|
| Category:British Government Programs |
rename |
August 29
|
| Category:British radio DJs |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 15
|
| Category:British video game companies |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 21
|
| Category:Britt Allcroft |
delete, precedent |
August 6
|
| Category:Buildings and structures in the Palestinian territories |
delete |
August 7
|
| Category:Bully |
delete |
August 27
|
| Category:Calvinist artists and writers |
no consensus |
August 31
|
| Category:Cannomys |
upmerge, per Wikipedia:WikiProject_Tree_of_Life#Categories, and while there doesn't seem to be a consensus of what to do with this, there appears to be a consensus to do something besides "keep". |
August 11
|
| Category:Casualties of Battle of Karbala |
Delete. |
August 7
|
| Category:Category Film |
speedy delete. Not a category, seems to have been set up for the sole purpose of containing (promoting?) an article someone created about themselves |
August 28
|
| Category-Class |
rename, to Category-class X pages |
August 20
|
| Children of category:Armoured fighting vehicles by era |
rename and merge as nominated |
August 20
|
| Category:Chinese erhu players |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Chinese mythology in anime |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 7
|
| Category:Christian folklore |
no consensus |
August 14
|
| Category:Christianity in Birmingham |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Christmas stories |
merge |
August 17
|
| Category:Cinemas and movie theaters in Georgia |
Rename, as nominated to avoid ambiguity |
August 7
|
| Category:Cities, towns and villages in the Palestinian territories |
delete |
August 7
|
| Category:Classical music in popular culture |
Speedy Delete per CSD:C1. |
August 5
|
| Category:Code Lyoko video games |
delete |
August 3
|
| Category:Comedy Central Roast |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Comic book founders |
merge |
August 9
|
| Category:Comic book terrorists |
upmerge to Category:Fictional terrorists |
August 21
|
| Category:Companies Based on Long Island |
speedy rename. |
August 2
|
| Category:Competitors for the United States at the 1904 Summer Olympics |
upmerge to Category:Olympic competitors for the United States |
August 18
|
| Category:Conservatories |
merge |
August 20
|
| Constitution Party members by U.S. state |
merge |
August 24
|
| Category:Converts from Judaism |
no consensus |
August 3
|
| Category:Convicted child sex offenders |
delete |
August 8
|
| Category:County Durham Valleys and Dales |
rename |
August 22
|
| Category:County Roads in Volusia County, Florida |
(speedy) rename as nominated |
August 17
|
| Category:Criminals from Cincinnati |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 12
|
| Category:Criticism involving the September 11, 2001 attacks, Category:Alternative theories of September 11, 2001 attacks and Category:Groups challenging the official account of 9/11 |
Since there was a consensus to merge the first two, but not to what, I'll merge Category:Criticism involving the September 11, 2001 attacks into Category:Alternative theories of September 11, 2001 attacks. If this is not acceptable, another CFD can be ran but at least the articles are in one category. As for Category:Groups challenging the official account of 9/11, there seemed to be a consensus to keep it as a separate category and to rename it, but no consensus as to what. |
August 1
|
| Category:Cult suicides |
no consensus |
August 17
|
| Category:Curb Your Enthusiasm |
delete |
August 3
|
| Category:Dan Quayle |
delete |
August 27
|
| Category:Daniel Dennett |
delete |
August 26
|
| Category:Dark Angel (band) |
delete per precedent |
August 22
|
| Category:Dark epic fantasy/Science fiction novel |
delete. In the absence of any main article that might describe the category's scope, the two entries to be recatted under Category:Novels by Paul Edwin Zimmer |
August 15
|
| Category:Dartmouth College trustees |
delete and listify, non-defining characteristic. NB, the cat's current entries already listified at the Board of Trustees of Dartmouth College article |
August 20
|
| Category:Daughter of the Lioness and related |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 1
|
| Category:David Guetta |
delete |
August 20
|
| Category:DC Comics crises |
merge |
August 25
|
| Category:Death in the United States |
delete, no objection to creating new cats if somebody can find a suitable objectively definable purpose |
August 8
|
| Category:Death of Joseph Smith, Jr. |
delete |
August 15
|
| Category:Deaths due to shipwrecks |
rename |
August 27
|
| Category:Deceased Police series characters |
delete |
August 5
|
| Category:Deceased Soap opera characters |
Delete, and SALT |
August 5
|
| Category:Deceased TV characters |
SPEEDY DELETE and BLOCK |
August 8
|
| Category:Defunct airlines of Faroe Islands |
rename. We do have a cat tree for defunct airlines, do make a shared nom if you want to change that |
August 4
|
| Category:Denialism |
no consensus bordering on keep, so keep |
August 15
|
| Category:Denny Laine |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:DeviantART |
delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Diamond albums |
delete and it seems that a list is not required |
August 15
|
| Category:Dinosaurs of Eastern North America |
delete |
August 19
|
| Category:Dipodoid rodents |
merge |
August 4
|
| Category:Divorced wives of future Roman emperors |
delete |
August 15
|
| Category:Dizzy Gillespie |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial video games |
merge zeros, ones, and twos, per discussion |
August 22
|
| Category:Early converts to Islam |
delete. Seems to have been recently interposed in an existing category scheme, almost as an alternative for the pre-existing Category:Sahaba. As such, doesn't seem necessary |
August 17
|
| Category:Echimyidae |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 3
|
| Category:Ed Roth |
delete |
August 30
|
| Category:Ed, Edd n Eddy |
delete |
August 29
|
| Category:Effects |
delete |
August 16
|
| Category:Egyptian rock bands |
rename Category:Egyptian rock bands to Category:Egyptian rock music groups |
August 11
|
| Category:Elapids |
rename/merge as nominated, per commons cat and per Elapidae |
August 3
|
| Category:Elemental superheroes |
delete |
August 19
|
| Category:Embassies and High Commissions of the United Kingdom |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Embassies of the United States |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Emergency Rooms in New York City |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Emily Osment Movies |
delete |
August 29
|
| Category:English art historians |
not to merge |
August 9
|
| Category:English of Nigerian descent |
rename |
August 4
|
| Category:English students' unions |
keep |
August 3
|
| Category:Environmental Protection Agency |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Eponymous musician categories - B |
delete per precedent |
August 1
|
| Eponymous musician categories - C |
delete, precedent |
August 2
|
| Eponymous musician categories - D |
delete; the nominator's rationale was not addressed by those who wished these categories kept |
August 11
|
| Eponymous musician categories - F |
delete all |
August 17
|
| Eponymous musician categories - G |
delete all per precedent |
August 22
|
| Eponymous musician categories - H |
delete per precedent |
August 3
|
| Eponymous musician categories - J |
delete all |
August 26
|
| Eponymous musician categories - L |
delete all |
August 28
|
| Category:Esperantists |
delete, we should not categorize people by the language they speak, nor by opinion or advocacy. If necessary, there is already a list of speakers/advocates at Esperantist |
August 28
|
| Category:Estonian ministers |
rename |
August 15
|
| Category:Ethnic nationalism |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Exile |
Keep, but move individual biographies to Category:Exiles. × |
August 14
|
| Category:Extrasolar planets with unofficial names |
delete |
August 18
|
| Category:Fabrosaurs |
delete |
August 19
|
| Category:Fashion in popular culture |
merge |
August 16
|
| FBI Top Ten Most Wanted |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Fellows of the IEEE |
rename |
August 27
|
| Category:Fellows of the RSC |
delete |
August 27
|
| Category:Fictional alcoholics |
Delete. |
August 5
|
| Category:Fictional bulimics |
Delete. |
August 5
|
| Fictional characters by U.S. city |
rename all |
August 16
|
| Category:Fictional characters with multiple forms |
delete |
August 24
|
| Category:Fictional fraternities |
delete |
August 25
|
| Category:Fictional Freemasons |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:Fictional Manslaughter victims |
delete |
August 1
|
| Category:Fictional octopi |
merge |
August 28
|
| Category:Fictional Science Fiction Ground Vehicles |
delete |
August 23
|
| Category:Fictional stabbing victims |
delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Fictional towns and cities |
Keep |
August 11
|
| Category:Fictional waiters and waitresses |
rename to Category:Fictional waiting staff |
August 27
|
| Category:Fighting Talk |
delete, overcategorisation |
August 17
|
| Category:Files uploaded by User:Jeff G. |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:Films by shooting location and Category:Films shot in Poland |
no consensus |
August 14
|
| Category:Films in the Criterion Collection |
delete. |
August 20
|
| Category:Films re-edited by the studio or otherwise |
delete |
August 29
|
| Category:Fiona (singer) |
delete |
August 16
|
| Category:Flamboyant sports supporters |
delete |
August 15
|
| Category:Forbes |
delete; as a category about people, this should be deleted per eponymous precedent and OCAT. as a category about the company, I agree with DGG and his/her arguments, but in this case, there really aren't enough articles to sustain a category, especially when all of the articles are already linked to from Forbes. |
August 6
|
| Category:Foreign missions of Barbados |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Foreign missions of Canada |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Fossorial muroids |
no consensus |
August 3
|
| Category:Four Funnel Ocean Liners |
rename to Category:Ocean liners with four funnels |
August 1
|
| Category:Fred Astaire films |
delete |
August 26
|
| Category:Free albums |
rename |
August 16
|
| Category:Free image placeholders |
merge |
August 5
|
| Category:Freemason officers |
delete. |
August 17
|
| Category:French company stubs:film studios |
delete, malformed/misintentioned |
August 15
|
| Category:Fuse VJs |
merge |
August 5
|
| Category:G4 hosts and staff |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Gary Moore |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:General CVG character subboxes |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 3
|
| Category:Geography of the Palestinian territories |
delete |
August 7
|
| Category:George Strait |
delete |
August 22
|
| Georgia category |
rename all |
August 19
|
| Category:Georgia culture and subcats |
Delete, CSD G7 by creator request. -- |
August 14
|
| Category:Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets men's baseball players |
rename, per nomination |
August 20
|
| Category:Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets men's golf players |
rename as nominated |
August 20
|
| Category:German embassies |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Gertrude Stein operas and plays |
rename |
August 26
|
| Category:Giantesses |
delete, as all contents are already in category:Fictional giants |
August 27
|
| Category:Gimme Gimme Gimme |
delete |
August 24
|
| Category:Golf clubs and courses in the People's Republic of China |
rename |
August 12
|
| Category:Gotham City Police Department members |
delete |
August 14
|
| Category:Granite Broadcasting Corporation stations |
Withdrawn |
August 4
|
| Category:Greek country music songwriters |
delete |
August 30
|
| Category:Greek shooters |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 13
|
| Category:Halo space weapons |
delete as empty and unneeded |
August 23
|
| Category:Hancock's Half Hour actors |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:Haskell compilers |
rename |
August 22
|
| Category:Health professionals |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:Health risks |
no consensus. A quick poll of google for "health risk" shows that Radiant! is indeed correct. Laser printers, sprouts, sexual intercourse, loneliness, leaky roofs, mold outbreaks, and rodents were found to be health risks, yet if they were added to the category, I'm sure they'd be immediately removed. It is subjective, period. However, Johnbod pointed out that if it didn't exist, something would replace it. There was no suggestions as to what to rename it to, therefore the no consensus. |
August 1
|
| Category:Heralds of Galactus |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Heterodontosaurs |
delete per convincing arguments by Firsfron |
August 19
|
| Category:High school debate films |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Hinder |
delete |
August 26
|
| Category:Hindu schools in India |
delete. I checked the articles that were removed, and indeed they made no mention of being hindu schools. That left one that did say it was. This can be recreated if more articles about hindu schools are written. |
August 3
|
| Category:Historic English Festivals |
merge Category:Historic English Festivals to Category:Festivals in England |
August 10
|
| Category:Hogwarts employees |
keep |
August 20
|
| Category:Holiday parks in the UK |
rename |
August 5
|
| Category:Hollywood film studios |
merge to Category:Film production companies of the United States |
August 14
|
| Category:Holocaust in Estonia |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Holocaust in popular culture |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 10
|
| Category:Homage superheroes and Category:Homage supervillains |
delete both |
August 26
|
| Category:Home and Away |
delete |
August 23
|
| Category:Homophobia |
keep |
August 30
|
| Category:Hubert Evans Non-Fiction Prize |
delete |
August 18
|
| Category:Human rights activists |
keep |
August 15
|
| Category:Hungarian Freemasons |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:Ian Curtis |
delete |
August 26
|
| Category:Ig Nobel Prize winners |
no consensus |
August 1
|
| Category:Ig Nobel Prize |
delete (unanimous) |
August 9
|
| Category:Images of Portland,Oregon |
speedy by Vegaswikian. × |
August 18
|
| Category:Immanuel Velikovsky |
delete per precedent and WP:OCAT, and to a lesser extent, Dugwiki |
August 20
|
| Category:In other media |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:Inactive bots on Wikipedia |
merge |
August 31
|
| Category:Indian female dancers |
merge Category:Indian female dancers to Category:Indian dancers |
August 11
|
| Category:Indian female television personalities |
merge Category:Indian female television personalities to Category:Indian television personalities |
August 11
|
| Category:Indian Philosophy |
speedy delete as empty and as creator had made mistake |
August 28
|
| Category:Indian women artists |
merge and listify per Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2007 August_4#Category:Indian women film actors below. |
August 4
|
| Category:Indian women athletes |
merge Category:Indian women athletes to Category:Indian athletes |
August 11
|
| Category:Indian women film actors |
listify. An important factor here is that our entire category tree of actors does not subdivide by gender, as evidenced (among others) in the precedent cited by ProveIt. It is certainly true, as Cgingold suggests, that "some non-Indian Wiki readers may be interested in reading about female Indian film actors", but to facilitate that we should write an article like Women in Indian film - such an article is far more informative than having a "woman" tag on the bottom of these actor articles. And, to avert an old chestnut, changing a category into a list is not a loss of information. So let's make a list article of these actresses and merge the categories. (note: list here) |
August 4
|
| Category:Indian women film choreographers |
merge Category:Indian women film choreographers to Category:Indian film choreographers |
August 11
|
| Category:Indie Record Stores |
delete |
August 19
|
| Category:Influenced by the Work of Bertolt Brecht |
delete, per consensus below plus concerns over "influenced by" categories to be speculative |
August 24
|
| Category:International Hockey Hall of Fame |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Iqbal scholars |
keep |
August 31
|
| Category:Iranian freemasons |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:Iranian women mathematicians |
merge, as nominated |
August 20
|
| Category:Iraq War Supporters |
delete, textbook example of OCAT |
August 4
|
| Category:Italian dukes |
merge |
August 30
|
| Category:Jazz ensembles |
not to rename |
August 4
|
| Category:Jeff Buckley |
delete |
August 6
|
| Category:Jewish atheists |
no consensus. I understand that Jewish Christians was already deleted, and if "Jewish" meant nothing other than a religious belief, this would be a delete too. But there are ethnic Jews (as opposed to religious Jews). So yes, there can be ethnic Jews who have no belief in God. |
August 25
|
| Category:Jewish Roman Catholics |
delete |
August 29
|
| Category:Journalists accused of fabrication or plagiarism |
delete. The argument for creation of Category:Journalism scandals has merit, but people are not "scandals". Whatever Category:Journalism scandals might contain, it should not contain biographical articles |
August 10
|
| Category:Judges of Northern District of New York |
rename |
August 22
|
| Category:Kibbutz Dati |
rename |
August 29
|
| Category:Kongs |
merge to Category:Donkey Kong characters and Category:Fictional apes |
August 19
|
| Category:Kyle XY |
} Deleted, and please notify me on my |
August 11
|
| Category:Lahore University of Management Sciences |
delete |
August 18
|
| Lakes of California |
merge |
August 9
|
| Category:Late Night Poker series winners |
delete |
August 20
|
| Category:Latter Day Saint artists |
delete per WP:OCAT |
August 31
|
| Category:Latter-day Saint writers |
rename and prune Category:Latter-day Saint writers to Category:Latter Day Saint writers and delete Category:Latter-day Saint media personalities |
August 31
|
| Category:Law Schools in Long Island |
merge |
August 29
|
| Category:Law Schools in Northern New Jersey |
merge |
August 29
|
| Category:Law Schools in the New York Metropolitan Area |
merge |
August 29
|
| Category:League of Extraordinary Gentlemen characters |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:Legacy characters |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Legends of Wrestling |
delete all. In the future, please don't depopulate categories that are under discussion |
August 12
|
| Category:Leporids |
cat redir |
August 4
|
| Category:LGBT scholars |
no consensus. Question for anyone still listening: Why couldn't we just recat these 7 or so people into the already existing Category:Gender studies and Category:Academics. Do we need a new category? Just a thought in case someone wants to renominate this. After speaking with |
August 29
|
| Category:Library reference desk |
delete |
August 2
|
| Category:Light Rail in Minnesota |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:List of Family Matters characters |
merge |
August 26
|
| Category:List of military dictatorships in Latin America films |
no consensus to delete, rename to Category:Military dictatorships in Latin America films to remove the word "list" and to match the main article |
August 21
|
| Category:List of ships of Russia by project number |
delete |
August 21
|
| Category:List of Southern convenience stores |
rename to Category:Convenience stores of the United States |
August 21
|
| Category:List of UNICEF Goodwill Ambassadors |
delete. |
August 6
|
| Category:Lists of films by location |
rename |
August 14
|
| Category:Lists of films shot by location |
rename |
August 14
|
| Category:Liszt |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Lithuanian journals |
delete |
August 23
|
| Category:Lithuanian Magazines |
speedied |
August 23
|
| Category:Lithuanian priests |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:Local government in England by county |
rename |
August 18
|
| Category:Lollipop Lust Kill |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Long articles |
delete |
August 19
|
| Lord Lieutenants |
rename |
August 8
|
| Category:Louisiana State University at Shreveport alumni |
merge as nominated. It seems someone's already emptied the cat |
August 17
|
| Category:Louisville religion |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Machinima based on The Sims 2 |
delete |
August 18
|
| Magazine people by magazine |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Main cities and towns in Nagaland |
merge |
August 31
|
| Category:Major Media Scandals |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Mankiewicz family |
keep |
August 6
|
| Category:Maritime Plymouth |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Martial arts of Indonesia |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 13
|
| Category:Martial arts of Malay archipelago |
no consensus, but rename per |
August 13
|
| Category:Martyred priests |
rename |
August 22
|
| Category:Marvin, the Paranoid Android songs |
keep |
August 14
|
| Category:Mash-ups |
rename |
August 8
|
| Category:Massachusetts Attorneys General |
keep |
August 17
|
| Category:Mega64 |
delete |
August 19
|
| Category:Meitner |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:Members of ISSR |
rename |
August 27
|
| Category:Merchant Services |
speedy rename |
August 11
|
| Category:Methodist artists |
delete. |
August 30
|
| Category:Metro Conference Men's Basketball Tournament Venues |
Keep, WillC brings up a good point, we already are categorizing many other venues by event. |
August 15
|
| Category:Mexican embassies |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Mexican musical groups by time period |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 15
|
| Category:Miley Cyrus |
delete |
August 10
|
| Category:Monographs |
no consensus |
August 22
|
| Category:Monumental wastes of human energy |
speedy delete. "Politically motivated nonsense" is right. × |
August 19
|
| More Kitakyushu macrons |
rename |
August 17
|
| Category:Mormon temples |
rename |
August 31
|
| Category:Moroccan Eurovision songs |
Keep - a category that is part of a wider scheme (non-admin closure) |
August 11
|
| Category:Motion Picture Director/Writer |
delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Motorcycle gangs |
upmerge to Category:Motorcycle clubs |
August 6
|
| Category:Murdered prisoners |
rename/merge to Category:Prisoners murdered in custody |
August 15
|
| Category:Murdered Roman Catholic priests |
no consensus |
August 14
|
| Category:Murdered Roman Catholic priests |
rename, apparently, but there seems to be a lack of suggestions of what to rename to. I'll relist this (for renaming, not deletion) to find suggestions |
August 9
|
| Category:Murdering doctors |
rename to Category:Doctors convicted of murdering their patients |
August 2
|
| Category:Musicals by Bertolt Brecht |
delete, these plays are already categorized in existing Bertolt Brecht categories, and per nomination |
August 22
|
| Category:Myoxidae |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 3
|
| Category:Narnia |
rename/merge as nominated, except for category:The Roar of Love and category:Narnia adaptations, both of which will upmerge to category:The Chronicles of Narnia |
August 5
|
| Category:NASCAR terms |
rename NASCAR as nominated, auto racing to Motorsport terminology |
August 7
|
| Category:Nasta |
delete |
August 4
|
| Category:National museums of Australia |
keep. |
August 23
|
| Category:National parks of Portugal |
keep |
August 19
|
| Category:Nature parks in Portugal |
no consensus |
August 21
|
| Category:Nebulous |
delete. |
August 17
|
| Neighborhoods in the United States |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 3
|
| Category:Never raced F1 cars |
rename |
August 9
|
| Category:New images to be reviewed |
delete |
August 4
|
| Category:New Warriors |
delete |
August 2
|
| Category:New World Order wrestlers |
no consensus |
August 17
|
| Category:New World rats and mice |
rename/merge as nominated to Category:Sigmodontinae, Category:Neotominae, and Category:Tylomyinae |
August 11
|
| Category:New York Times Best Seller |
delete |
August 27
|
| Category:Non-alcoholic beer |
delete |
August 16
|
| Category:Non-article Cities pages |
already deleted |
August 19
|
| Category:Notable Alumni |
delete |
August 30
|
| Category:No_image_available |
Speedy deleted |
August 17
|
| Category:NUMB3RS |
delete |
August 4
|
| Occupation by city |
delete |
August 12
|
| Olympic competitors by nation and year |
upmerge all |
August 31
|
| Category:One member bands |
delete |
August 30
|
| Category:Orchidaceae |
merge |
August 23
|
| Category:Orders of magnitude (energy) |
delete |
August 21
|
| Category:Orders, decorations, and medals of the German Democratic Republic |
rename |
August 25
|
| Orphaned year cats |
keep Category:2007 Summer Universiade, delete the rest. × |
August 14
|
| Category:Orthodox Jewish Anti-Zionism |
no consensus |
August 22
|
| Category:Owners of Slytherin's Locket |
delete |
August 8
|
| Category:Pakastini communists |
Rename, the author has now speedy requested this spelling error be deleted |
August 14
|
| Category:Pakistan Youth Organisation(PYO) stubs |
delete, malformed/misintended |
August 15
|
| Category:Pakistani women's ODI cricketers |
withdrawn and listed at WP:CFD/S for speedy renaming. — |
August 5
|
| Category:Palaces in Italy |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 5
|
| Category:Parody characters |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Parsers |
rename |
August 22
|
| Category:Paul Dessau |
recategorize, then delete. I created and populated the composition category, and all that remains are people that worked with Dessau |
August 26
|
| Category:Pearl of Great Price (Mormonism) |
rename |
August 31
|
| People by school in England |
no consensus |
August 28
|
| Category:People from Cottingley |
rename |
August 29
|
| People from Japanese cities |
upmerge all |
August 17
|
| Category:People from Reading |
merge/redirect |
August 1
|
| Category:People from Sherbrooke |
merge |
August 26
|
| Category:People from Stone |
merge |
August 15
|
| Category:People from Suriname |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 14
|
| Category:People imprisoned for terrorism |
rename |
August 14
|
| Category:People in Anime |
upmerge |
August 6
|
| Category:People in Kitakyushu |
rename |
August 17
|
| Category:People who attended Troy High School (Michigan) |
delete |
August 15
|
| Category:People with clinical depression |
delete |
August 5
|
| Category:People with craters of the Moon named after them |
listify. And list seems already there, I'll give it a few days to cross-check that against the cat, then delete the cat |
August 8
|
| Category:Physical infrastructure |
no consensus |
August 11
|
| Category:Physicians from Cincinnati |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Pilot Cans at the Queer of God |
speedy delete. Obscure reference to a song by The Flaming Lips |
August 9
|
| Category:PIRA killings |
delete |
August 3
|
| Category:Play School presenters |
delete |
August 16
|
| Category:Pointer Sisters |
delete |
August 15
|
| Category:Polar exploration by Russia and Soviet Union |
Rename, as nominated |
August 6
|
| Category:Politicians of Afghanistan |
merge |
August 28
|
| Category:Portland artists |
merge |
August 30
|
| Presidents of X University |
rename |
August 25
|
| Category:Primrose Hill Gang |
delete |
August 7
|
| Category:Prince films |
prune and rename to Category:Films directed by Prince |
August 2
|
| Category:Proofreaders al-en |
closed and moved to UCFD |
August 11
|
| Category:Proposed states and union territories in India |
keep. No prejudice against future attempt to rename |
August 31
|
| Category:Protected deleted categories |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Protestant Curch in Lithuania |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:Public services by city |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:Public services in Cincinnati, Ohio |
delete |
August 8
|
| Category:Puerto Rican assassinated people |
merge |
August 5
|
| Category:Quack medicine |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Questions/Items/poeple that may have to do with the creation of the Universe |
delete |
August 7
|
| Category:Raëlian actors |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Raëlian bishops |
keep |
August 11
|
| Category:Raëlian guitarists |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Raëlian national guides |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Raëlian singers |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Raëlians by occupation |
delete, already moved |
August 15
|
| Category:Raëlism and women |
delete |
August 11
|
| Random rape categories |
merge. Everybody wants them gone, and the delete votes seem to be merge votes in disguise. The "attempt" one will be deleted, as it doesn't accurately match the target category. Please note that I also am merging Category:Fictional man-on-man gang rape victims |
August 24
|
| Category:Rats |
upmerge/delete. You are free to discuss removing the cat at the article in question since consensus was disputed regarding the upmerge |
August 11
|
| Category:Ray Lamontagne |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Reality films |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Recent deaths |
keep. This was going to be a delete, based upon pretty much every delete argument given. But if we are going to keep the template (which I don't agree with personally, but that's just my opinion), the category is useful for keeping track of what articles it's on. I checked all of the articles in the category, and none of the people have died earlier than July. So it is being kept up to date. |
August 2
|
| Rectors of Scottish universities |
rename |
August 23
|
| Reservoirs in California |
merge |
August 9
|
| Category:RiffTrax |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:Roads and highways in the Interior of British Columbia |
merge to category:Interior of British Columbia |
August 27
|
| Category:Roads in Simcoe County |
no consensus |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman equites |
rename both |
August 6
|
| Category:Roman propraetors |
rename as nominated, but merge Category:Roman governors by type to Category:Ancient Roman governors. × |
August 19
|
| Category:Roman women in ancient warfare |
rename |
August 6
|
| Category:Romanians |
merge |
August 15
|
| Category:Royal Shakespeare Company members |
keep |
August 18
|
| Category:Runestones, Danish isles |
rename |
August 22
|
| Category:Runestones, Jutland |
merge to Category:Runestones in Denmark |
August 22
|
| Category:Runestones, Skåneland |
rename to Category:Runestones in Scania |
August 22
|
| Category:Russian accusations of Nazism in Estonia |
delete |
August 14
|
| Russian and Soviet military equipment |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 21
|
| Category:Russian Freemasons |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:Savannah Black Leaders |
merge |
August 1
|
| Category:Science fiction Westerns |
no rename/withdrawn. If I understand the nominator correctly, it was originally intended to recategorise a number of entries in one to the other, more appropriate category; the nominator has since performed this recategorisation by hand. Since the two cats cover different topics and are viably separate, then no futher action is required |
August 22
|
| Category:Sciuridae |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 3
|
| Category:Screenshots of Cold Case episodes |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 1
|
| Category:Scrubs |
delete |
August 5
|
| Category:Secondary Road |
rename Category:Secondary Road to Category:Secondary roads in the Republic of Ireland |
August 25
|
| Category:Secretaries of State of Massachusetts |
rename as nominated |
August 17
|
| Category:Sector General articles |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 15
|
| Category:Senior Officers of the AGIR |
rename |
August 16
|
| Category:Serbian embassies |
rename |
August 24
|
| Sesame (uncategorized) |
delete |
August 8
|
| Settlements established before 1500 |
delete all, as empty now, but discussion can continue elsewhere |
August 15
|
| Category:Seven Network reporters |
merge |
August 12
|
| Category:Shakespearean actors |
no consensus |
August 18
|
| Category:Shark (TV Series) |
delete |
August 5
|
| Category:Silly People |
speedily deleted by |
August 18
|
| Category:Simpsons episodes named after songs |
delete |
August 26
|
| Category:Single covers |
delete |
August 20
|
| Category:SK Group |
void. There's no rush here. Let's determine the fate of the articles over at the AfD discussion first. Once we know how many articles we're dealing with, we can discuss whether the category is appropriate. × |
August 24
|
| Category:Skyteam Alliance |
rename |
August 15
|
| Category:Smallville characters |
keep |
August 10
|
| Category:Soccer in South Africa |
no consensus |
August 30
|
| Category:Socialites from Cincinnati |
merge into Category:American socialites and Category:People from Cincinnati |
August 12
|
| Category:Software companies by nationality |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Soleilmoon label |
rename |
August 28
|
| Some American actors by ethnicity |
delete. Note that the argument of "Categories can be misused but they are governed by the same policies as anb article" is incorrect, as there are several policies that apply to articles but not categories, and vice versa. And I find the argument of "keep for procedural reasons and renominate each one separately" not compelling, per WP:BURO |
August 8
|
| Category:Songs about queer issues |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 10
|
| Category:Songs that radio no longer plays |
Delete, unverifiable, not useful, WP:POINT |
August 6
|
| Category:South Asian artists |
recategorize articles and delete |
August 18
|
| Category:South Tyrol |
keep (no rename) |
August 29
|
| Category:Spanish dukes |
delete (and no upmerge) |
August 30
|
| Category:Spawn characters |
merge |
August 23
|
| Category:Spider-Man film series actors |
delete |
August 5
|
| Category:Sporting siblings |
delete |
August 6
|
| Category:Sportspersons from Edinburgh |
merge into Category:People from Edinburgh |
August 12
|
| Category:SPT railway stations |
no consensus for rename |
August 9
|
| Category:Squares of Adelaide |
rename |
August 1
|
| Category:Star Trek events |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Star Trek music |
merge |
August 1
|
| Category:Star Trek rank insignia |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Star Trek soundtracks |
delete |
August 13
|
| Category:Star Trek stars |
merge |
August 22
|
| Category:Star Wars companies |
DELETE |
August 14
|
| Category:StarCraft storyline |
merge |
August 9
|
| State highway categories in the United States |
rename as nominated except for Georgia (renamed to Category:State highways in Georgia (U.S. state) to match other Georgia roads categories), Oregon (renamed to Category:State routes in Oregon to match syntax), DC (renamed to Category:Routes in the District of Columbia to match syntax), and Massachusetts and Rhode Island (untouched for now). The latter four may be renamed if they can be brought in line by consensus later on |
August 25
|
| Category:Steve Hackett songs |
delete. × |
August 14
|
| Category:Steve Hackett |
delete |
August 14
|
| Category:Student television stations in the United Kingdom |
keep |
August 4
|
| Category:Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip |
delete |
August 23
|
| Sub-cats of Category:Raëlian beliefs and practices |
delete, already moved |
August 15
|
| Subcats of Category:American Latter Day Saints |
upmerge all LDS-by-state categories' contents to parent cat, then delete |
August 15
|
| Category:Tables |
rename/merge Category:Tables to Category:Wikipedia tables; leave Category:Tables as a cat redirect to category:Tables (furniture) |
August 14
|
| Category:Taiwanese Dancers |
rename |
August 19
|
| Category:Talkshow with Spike Feresten |
delete |
August 5
|
| Category:The Chris Moyles Show team members |
rename/merge as nominated, and above |
August 15
|
| Category:The Class Screenshots |
rename/merge as nominated. it appears that Category:Screenshots of television is for non-free screenshots that is populated via template. |
August 1
|
| Category:The L Word |
delete per precedent |
August 5
|
| Category:The Predators albums |
keep |
August 27
|
| Category:The Ramones albums |
rename all |
August 30
|
| Category:The Simpsons episode list infobox templates |
keep. Nominator's rationale no longer applies since the cat has been populated. Not enough opinions expressed to determine whether the populated cat should exist. Circeus or anyone else is welcome to try to consolidate the templates in with the main infobox |
August 1
|
| Category:The Tomorrow People |
rename. |
August 26
|
| Theme parks |
rename the first, delete the second |
August 30
|
| Category:Theories |
no consensus / withdrawn |
August 16
|
| Category:Thomas Corker |
delete |
August 19
|
| Three Sub-cats of Category:Raëlism |
delete, already moved |
August 15
|
| Category:Time Magazine 100 Most Influential People 2007 |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:Title Tracks |
delete |
August 6
|
| Category:Tonight Show people |
delete |
August 12
|
| Category:Tony Humphries albums |
delete |
August 16
|
| Category:Topics relating to criminology covered by the CCM |
listify/delete. See List of criminology topics covered by the Crime Classification Manual |
August 11
|
| Category:Topics |
delete |
August 24
|
| Category:Transformers Movie Decepticons |
Delete, overcat |
August 15
|
| Category:Translators al-en |
closed and moved to UCFD. see Wikipedia:User_categories_for_discussion#Category:Translators_al-en |
August 11
|
| Category:Trends journals |
delete. The concept of an organizing principle for redirects (say, as under category:Middle-earth redirects) is fine and workable as long as it is under a structure organized by a WikiProject. But this is one editor's well-meant attempt to create a process without consensus, and it doesn't work. There are thousands of categories that could have this treatment, but only a very few that come with the personnel to maintain it. I put the main article into category:Elsevier scientific journals, and also took the opportunity to do the same with Current Opinion, thus emptying category:Current Opinion journals and making it eligible for deletion. Obviously, both of these categories can come back when there are many articles that deserve them, which I fully expect |
August 27
|
| Category:TUGS |
delete, precedent |
August 6
|
| Category:Turkish actresses |
merge as nominated |
August 27
|
| Category:Two Pints of Lager and a Packet of Crisps |
delete |
August 28
|
| UFC champions |
upmerge all |
August 9
|
| Category:UFO religions |
The result was nomination withdrawn |
August 20
|
| Category:Ukrainian embassies abroad |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:Ukrainian Nobel laureates |
keep. If some articles have been removed from this category, they should be restored |
August 26
|
| Category:Ultimate Marvel mutants |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 3
|
| Category:Ultimate Poker Challenge |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:Unitarian villages in Transylvania |
delete |
August 28
|
| Category:United Arab Emirati businessmen |
rename Category:United Arab Emirati businessmen to Category:United Arab Emirati businesspeople |
August 11
|
| Category:United States History |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 7
|
| Category:United States Supreme Court cases by date |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:United States thoroughbred racing Hall of Fame inductees |
rename to Category:United States Thoroughbred Racing Hall of Fame inductees |
August 31
|
| Category:University of Florida Gators Golfers |
rename |
August 24
|
| Category:US-headquartered, non-AMA-affiliated motorcycle clubs |
no consensus |
August 6
|
| Category:USACE lakes |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:User galleries |
delete |
August 22
|
| Category:Van Buren family |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:Vanity labels |
rename |
August 26
|
| Various neighbourhoods categories |
rename "Foo neighborhoods" per nomination as cleanup only. There was no consensus as to whether it should be of or in, and almost no discussion at all regarding American English vs British English. Recommend a discussion at Wikipedia:Naming conventions (categories) to get a broader consensus for of or in, and possibly the AE/BE issue, and then a relisting of all neighborhood categories here. |
August 15
|
| Category:Venezuelan |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:Vermont State House |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 1
|
| Category:Video game companies by nationality |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Video game developers from Sweden |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
| Category:Virtual Airline |
rename |
August 12
|
| Category:Vogue editors |
delete. Given the small scope of the category, I'd suggest simply keeping a list of those five editors in the main article, and/or employing succession boxes |
August 9
|
| Category:Wards of Barrow-in-Furness |
delete |
August 4
|
| Category:Waterloo Road |
delete |
August 11
|
| Category:Web services brokering companies |
speedy delete as empty |
August 23
|
| Category:West Point graduates |
rename/merge as nominated and leave as a category redirect. There is already Category:Non-graduate alumni of West Point to deal with the alumni who have not graduated. |
August 21
|
| Wetlands of California |
per Johnbod |
August 9
|
| Category:Whose Line Is It Anyway? actors |
delete |
August 1
|
| Category:Wikipedia editing advice |
merge |
August 22
|
| Category:Wikipedia humor |
snowball keep. This debate is generating more heat than light. Also, humor-pages have a strong precedent of being kept on MFD |
August 2
|
| Category:Wikipedia OmniMusica |
delete |
August 30
|
| Category:Wikipedia requested photographs of religious sites or objects |
speedy delete. × |
August 18
|
| Category:WikiProject MTV and subcategories |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:WikiProject Rugby league (State of Origin) articles by importance |
Speedy delete per CSD:C1. |
August 25
|
| Category:WikiProject Rugby league (State of Origin) articles by quality |
Speedy delete per CSD:C1. |
August 25
|
| Category:WikiProject U.S. Congress articles |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 20
|
| Category:WikiProject U.S. Congress representatives |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:WikiProject U.S. Congress senators |
delete |
August 9
|
| Category:Winnipeg tourism |
rename as nominated |
August 23
|
| Wives |
delete all |
August 15
|
| Category:Wolf Prize in Chemistry recipients |
keep, and rename as indicated. 'Keep', since the significance of the award, at least in the sciences, is demonstrable (even if not yet cited in the article itself), & its receipt would be a defining career moment. 'Rename', for accuracy |
August 24
|
| Category:Wolf Prize in Physics recipients |
keep, and rename to Category:Wolf Prize in Physics laureates, following result of Chemistry prize below. 'Keep', since the significance of the award, at least in the sciences, is demonstrable (even if not yet cited in the article itself), & its receipt would be a defining career moment. 'Rename', for accuracy |
August 24
|
| Category:Wolf Prize recipients |
keep, and rename as indicated. 'Keep', since the significance of the award, at least in the sciences, is demonstrable (even if not yet cited in the article itself), & its receipt would be a defining career moment. 'Rename', for accuracy. The Physics & Chemistry prizes to be parented to this one, and other symmetrical (re)assignments done as needed |
August 24
|
| Category:Wolves in popular culture |
rename to Category:Wolves in film |
August 1
|
| Category:Women by cause of death |
rename to Category:Causes of death specific to women |
August 10
|
| Category:Women in comics |
split and sort into Category:Women comics writers and Category:Women comics artists |
August 27
|
| Category:World Poker Tour champions |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:World Series of Poker Tournament of Champions winners |
delete |
August 17
|
| Category:Yoshi characters |
delete |
August 23
|
| Category:Zion's Camp participants |
delete |
August 23
|
| Category:Zion's Camp participants |
relisting to get further attention |
August 15
|
.jpg&action=edit&redlink=1){kind=link}
.jpg&action=edit&redlink=1){kind=link}
.jpg){kind=link}